Blog

Hernia mesh lawsuits now stand as one of the biggest medical device battles in the country. Patients accuse manufacturers of selling unsafe implants that caused harm instead of healing. Many report years of pain, repeated hospital stays, and lost quality of life. Some went through multiple surgeries to remove damaged mesh. Others now suffer permanent injuries that changed daily living. Families also seek justice after loved ones faced life-threatening complications.

Courts across the United States now manage thousands of these cases. Judges created multidistrict litigations, called MDLs, to organize lawsuits against each company. Bard, Covidien, Ethicon, and Atrium face the largest MDLs. State courts also hear separate cases outside the federal system. Together, these actions show the wide reach of the problem and the demand for accountability.

This litigation is a national fight. It pits powerful corporations against injured patients who want justice. Past settlements prove the scale of the damage, yet many victims still wait for answers. Upcoming trials in 2026 will shape future payouts and decide how long this fight continues.

What Is a Hernia Mesh Lawsuit?

Patients file lawsuits after defective mesh devices harm them. Mesh implants were created to support weak tissue during hernia repair. Many failed and led to complications.

Common problems include:

• Chronic pain

• Adhesions

• Mesh migration

• Bowel obstruction

• Infections

• Organ perforation

• Hernia recurrence

• Revision surgery

Companies and Mesh Products in Lawsuits

• C.R. Bard and its Davol unit, owned by Becton Dickinson, face lawsuits over Ventralex, Ventralight ST, PerFix Plug, 3DMax, Composix, Kugel, and Sepramesh.
• Ethicon, a Johnson & Johnson unit, faces claims over Physiomesh Flexible Composite Mesh, which was pulled from the market in 2016.
• Covidien, a Medtronic and Sofradim company, made Parietex and Symbotex meshes that are now central to lawsuits.

• Atrium Medical (Getinge / Maquet): C-QUR line such as Mosaic, V-Patch, TacShield, FX, CentriFX.

• Other manufacturers: W.L. Gore, Cook Medical, Strattice (biologic mesh made from pig tissue).

Each brand faces claims of design flaws, lack of warnings, and false safety claims.

Federal MDLs and Courts

Judges grouped thousands of lawsuits into MDLs. Each MDL focuses on one manufacturer:

• MDL 2846 – Bard Hernia Mesh, Southern District of Ohio.

• MDL 2782 – Ethicon Physiomesh, Northern District of Georgia.

• MDL 2753 – Atrium C-QUR Mesh, District of New Hampshire.

• MDL 3029 – Covidien Hernia Mesh, District of Massachusetts.

Updates in 2025

Lawsuits continue to grow across all MDLs:

• Bard MDL: Around 24,000 active cases remain after a 2024 settlement of 38,000 claims. New filings add to the total. The court will start an Inventory Settlement Process in 2027. Some victims may wait until 2029.

• The Covidien MDL has more than 2,000 active cases. The first bellwether trial is set for February 2026.

  A second follows in July 2026. Mediation efforts continue.

• Atrium MDL: About 436 cases remain. Most resolved through a $66 million settlement.

• Ethicon MDL: Most lawsuits have settled. Only a few remain.

• Strattice litigation: Federal and state cases move forward in New Jersey. The first bellwether trial is set for February 2026.

Settlement and Compensation

• The Bard settlement in 2024 set average payouts between $60,000 and $70,000. Quick-pay options gave $25,000 in simple cases and $2,500 in weak ones. Severe cases reached $900,000.

• Covidien Outlook: Expected payouts may exceed Bard amounts because of stronger injury claims. No settlement yet.

• Atrium Settlement: Confidential but reported near $66 million.

• Ethicon Settlement: Confidential settlements resolved most claims.

Past results guide current estimates:

• Bard Kugel Mesh: $184 million, average $70,000 per case.

• Manufacturers paid $900 million to settle vaginal mesh claims, averaging $45,000 each.

Steps in the Legal Process

Patients move through several stages when filing a claim:

1. Case review: A lawyer confirms the device type and injury details.

2. Complaint filed: Most use short-form complaints linked to MDL master complaints.

3. Discovery phase: Both sides exchange records and evidence.

4. Courts run bellwether trials to see jury reactions in sample cases.
5. Bellwether results often lead to settlements. Some cases still go before a jury.Others go to trial.

Why Strattice Cases Matter

Strattice uses pig tissue rather than synthetic mesh. Companies marketed it as a safer option. Patients say it still causes infection, tissue breakdown, and severe pain.

The FDA received over 450 adverse reports, including deaths.Courts plan to test these claims in trials set for 2026.

Results may change how biologic mesh is viewed in future litigation.

Key Issues Raised in Lawsuits

Patients accuse manufacturers of:

• Defective design

• Failure to warn

• Concealment of risks

• Causing severe injuries

Who Qualifies to File a Lawsuit?

You may qualify if:

• You had hernia mesh surgery after 2006.

• You developed complications more than 30 days later.

• Your case involved revision surgery or medical advice to remove the mesh.
• Your complications included pain, infection, bowel blockage, or organ injury.

Each state enforces strict deadlines. Contacting a lawyer early is essential.

Final Word

Patients harmed by mesh still have a clear path to justice.